I have a client that has me stumped. We installed a lovely new stone facade for a client, but their vision for the mantle has me at a loss. They like Minwax Carbon color stain, but want a deep color, non-grainy finish. The closest I've gotten is 2 coats on pre-stain conditioned Aspen, but it still has too much grain pattern. Any ideas on other species (tried all the usual ones, oak [too red], poplar [too green], pine [too grainy]) before I move into colored varnishes?

  • 3
    Aspen has too much grain showing?! Yikes. Is the client actually sure they want wood because it sounds like they want something pretty much featureless o_O For someone this picky I'd consider 'cheating', pick a fine-textured wood (like aspen or poplar), paint the wood to obscure 95% of what little grain variation there is and then use a coloured finish over the top. Needless to say you wouldn't tell them that's how you did it. – Graphus supports Monica Aug 17 at 23:19
  • Is their problem with the grain that they can see the color differences through the stain or that they can see the raised texture of the growth rings? – SaSSafraS1232 Aug 19 at 18:52
  • they don't like the color variation caused by the woodgrain. – Brian Alderson Aug 19 at 19:42
  • I'm thinking I'll try the aspen with pre-stain conditioner, 3 coats of stain, then tint down some urethane with the stain... – Brian Alderson Aug 19 at 19:43
  • Sorry if this is teaching grandma to suck eggs but any pre-stain treatment will reduce stain absorption, and will therefore automatically limit how dark you're going to get (by a considerable margin). This is unless you're using "gel stain", but if you're using that you don't need to pre-treat the wood in the first place. – Graphus supports Monica Aug 20 at 21:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.