I'm currently in the process of building a red cedar tabletop with laminated live edge slabs. Thickness should be around 7/4. However, I'm unsure what to use for finishing it. Given the wood is so soft, the abuse it will receive at a hunting lodge will be pretty significant.

I considered epoxy, however I learned the hard way that epoxy flood coats and wood movement are not good friends. Any advice is appreciated.

  • Reference: realcedar.com/indoor/finishing (But, as usual, polyurethane seems to be the toughest option these days.) – jdv Nov 8 at 18:55
  • 1
    I thought I'd have an existing Answer that I could point to that covers the basic query but surprisingly there doesn't appear to be one. Anyway, finish selection always comes down to the user's own choice at the end of the day. I presume you're familiar with the pros and cons of various finishes (a topic too big to cover properly in an Answer) so you have to pick what you're OK working with, and that you think will give you what you want in terms of looks and durability. And remember that no finish is a viable option, and it makes refreshing the surface periodically easiest! – Graphus Nov 8 at 19:23
  • "I considered epoxy, however I learned the hard way that epoxy flood coats and wood movement are not good friends." Indeed! And also, I think epoxy and similar finishes aren't ideally suited to softer substrates because a sharp knock can badly fracture the coating where it wouldn't if oak or anything harder were underneath. – Graphus Nov 8 at 19:31

Quickly, my answer is Epoxy, but to your point, there is wood movement to contend with, so the answer is not that simple. I guess my point is that epoxy is not a single product, and you might look into those epoxies more dedicated to finish than to adhesive applications.

My first attempt at Epoxy finish was with Bar Top, which is very viscus, and although trying to follow the instructions, I found that there is a lot of lore around it. First and foremost, mix the product well, then mix some more. In my case, wood movement would not have been an issue since it never setup completely. That's on me, not the product.

Once I cleared out my issues, that product is fantastic when you lay an initial thin (not viscosity, but rather depth) layer, working out the bubbles (with a heat gun) that will surely appear. The second layer tends to be the thick "Bar top" layer. That bar top, veneer over substrate, was solid for the three years I had the house.

Another product that I'm not sure is still available is a "water thin" two part that I found at James Town (http://jamestowndistributors.com/). Fine Woodworking did a study on longevity and found that this epoxy would not only "cure" punky wood, but for a door subject to weather, it provided a strong flexible base to any other finish such as Spar Varnish. I still keep what I have as a two part, and when I have to get a good finish on questionable wood (and Cedar tends to fall into that bucket) it is what I reach for. In my mind, you can decide to sand, reapply, sand, etc. or in my door's case, apply the epoxy, set, then sand and use your favorite varnish or other finish.

James Town now refers to https://www.jamestowndistributors.com/userportal/show_product.do?pid=97636 or "Penetrating Epoxy" I have not tried this replacement.

I know the other products out there can be inflexible once cured, but I've yet to see a failure with the Penetrating base.

Good luck, and know nothing is absolute here.

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.