I am refinishing a cedar chest. I took it down to the bare wood and applied water based wood conditioner. I was almost ready to stain but luckily I realized the stain I was about to apply is oil based.

What do I do?

Let the wood dry overnight and take it back to the bare wood? Or is a light sanding all I need?

  • So just for good measure, I sanded the lid of the cedar chest the next day, but forgot to sand the other part of the top still attached to the chest. The difference became clear when I wiped off the stain: the sanded lid absorbed the oil stain well, but the stain with the "wood conditioner" for water based stain wiped almost completely off. So I cleaned everything off with mineral spirits and sanded it back down to the bare wood. I re-stained it and both parts appear to have accepted the stain equally. Feb 27, 2017 at 23:14

1 Answer 1


You should have nothing to worry about as far as compatibility is concerned.

Let the wood dry overnight ...?

In actual fact it's usually a good idea to wait for this type of thing to fully dry even if the instructions say otherwise.

Given the time gap between you asking and reading an Answer you've almost certainly given it ample time!

For some added context, "wood conditioner" isn't really a thing. It's merely a marketing name for one of a number of products made to help lessen or prevent blotching in blotch-prone woods and as such it really has little use in any other context. Although it can be used to deliberately make any wood stain more lightly, you can do this in other ways without having to put something on the wood first and then have to wait for it to dry1.

In the past, before these products came on the scene, this same job was accomplished in other ways, e.g. using a thin application of shellac (sometimes referred to as a spitcoat) or glue size (diluted glue). An initial dilute application of varnish or lacquer can also be used, as can a coat of oil if that fits in with the overall finishing regimen. And all of these can still be used for the same purpose, without of course having to buy a specialised product that has no other use in the shop.

Most commercial "wood conditioner" is merely a type of diluted finish, i.e. nothing you couldn't make for yourself in two minutes, but with a huge mark-up on the price considering what's in the container is mostly thinners2.

1 Apply less heavily (most application instructions call for a huge excess to be applied, most of which ends up on the wiping rags and not on the wood!), dilute or thin the stain, wipe off sooner and/or more thoroughly, dampen the wood prior to application. Or buy/mix up a lighter colour to start with and apply it normally.

2 Just like with most "Danish oil", "teak oil" and wiping varnish.

  • "make any wood stain more lightly"? I would have helped you with an edit but am not entirely sure if you mean application or gradation.
    – bpedit
    Feb 26, 2017 at 19:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.